A new study conducted by the National Foundation for American Policy (NFAP) warns that proposed wage mandates for H-1B visa holders could make it significantly harder for U.S. companies to hire skilled foreign workers, particularly in the fields of science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. The research highlights concern over legislative proposals that would require employers to pay H-1B professionals at rates much higher than current market wages. This policy shift, NFAP argues, could lead to unintended consequences, including job losses, increased outsourcing, and a diminished U.S. workforce in key industries.
Potential Impact of Wage Increases
One of the major concerns outlined in the NFAP report is that the proposed wage changes would make hiring skilled foreign graduates financially unfeasible for many companies. The policy includes a provision requiring employers to pay at least the “median local wage” to H-1B workers. Since median wages in many professions are calculated based on individuals with over a decade of experience, applying these rates to entry-level professionals would result in drastically inflated salary requirements.
For example, an amendment introduced by Senator Bernie Sanders to the Laken Riley Act proposed raising wages for H-1B workers by as much as 72% in some cases. If enacted, this measure would mean that a newly graduated software developer in San Jose would need to be paid over $80,000 more per year than current law mandates. While the Senate did not vote on the amendment, similar proposals may resurface as Congress continues to debate immigration and labor reforms.
Challenges for Employers and Workers
NFAP argues that imposing such wage mandates could lead to a range of adverse effects, not only for employers but also for foreign-born workers and the broader U.S. economy. Currently, approximately 70% of full-time graduate students in electrical engineering and computer science programs at U.S. universities are international students. If hiring becomes prohibitively expensive, companies may either seek to relocate operations offshore or reduce hiring altogether, leaving these highly skilled graduates with limited employment opportunities in the United States.
Furthermore, the wage mandates could create disparities within the labor market. Under the proposed changes, employers would be required to pay foreign-born recent graduates significantly more than U.S. workers with greater experience. This imbalance could lead to legal challenges and concerns about fairness in hiring practices. Employers might also hesitate to hire international graduates due to the complex regulatory and financial burdens associated with compliance.
Historical Precedents and Legal Hurdles
The idea of imposing stringent wage requirements on H-1B workers is not new. Similar measures were proposed during the Trump administration but were ultimately struck down in court for violating administrative procedures. NFAP cautions that if Congress proceeds with new wage mandates, the policy could face similar legal challenges and unintended negative consequences. In the past, efforts to impose excessive wage requirements on foreign-born professionals have resulted in reduced job opportunities and an increase in companies shifting their workforce to other countries with more flexible labor policies.
Broader Economic and Industry Implications
The NFAP study suggests that increasing wage requirements for H-1B visa holders could have far-reaching effects on the U.S. economy and technological leadership. Industries such as artificial intelligence, semiconductor engineering, and cybersecurity rely heavily on highly skilled foreign workers. If these professionals are priced out of the job market, U.S. companies may struggle to fill critical positions, thereby slowing innovation and weakening the country’s position as a global technology leader.
Additionally, restrictive hiring policies could make the United States less attractive to top global talent. Countries such as Canada, the United Kingdom, and Australia have introduced policies aimed at attracting highly skilled foreign workers, and stringent U.S. wage mandates could further drive talent toward these competing markets. As policymakers continue to debate immigration and labor reforms, they must consider the potential downsides of imposing inflated wage requirements on H-1B visa holders. Instead of fostering job growth and economic stability, such mandates could ultimately weaken U.S. competitiveness in critical industries.
With a passion for news writing and a deep interest in Journalism, Bowrna wants to write articles that create an impact. Not only writing, she also has a passion for voiceovers and also aspires to become a Radio Jockey in the future. When not writing, she likes to listen to songs and dance to her heart's content. She is proficient in English, Tamil and Hindi.
Comments